They created golden money and messages that they attached to their trap to lure the little guy. This one was the best -
This is what it ended up looking like - a wooden ramp leading to a container that the leprechaun would drop into (thus the cushioning grass bottom). We also read on-line that because of their Irish background, leprechauns really enjoy potatoes. They put a couple of those in the container.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3d61e/3d61e1c90fadfceb4b3b8d171af7f04946d50c0a" alt=""
It was supposed to rain that night, so we moved the trap under the Rudy's covered porch, and this is what it looked like the next morning:
It was in disarray and covered with small green footprints! There was a note signed with the same footprint and a pot of golden chocolate bars for all to share as well.
What great smiles! See what I mean about being a new favorite holiday?